Commission:
Sheffield Town Trust.
Comment:
The Sheffield Town Trust, established in 1297, was for over 500 years one
of the main agents of local government and as such responsible for building
the first two Town Halls, supplying water, building roads and installing
street lighting. Its municipal responsibilities gradually passed to the
local authorities and it now acts as a charitable grant-giving body supporting
a wide range of good causes. It is believed to be the oldest charity still
operating in the country.
To commemorate its 700th anniversary, the Sheffield Town Trust organised
a competition for a sculpture in Town Hall Square to replace the Goodwin
Fountain which has been relocated in the Peace Gardens. An accompanying
leaflet stated that "The Sheffield Town Trust has applied for National
Lottery funds to help with its nationally significant commission....."
The Arts Council of England announced on 1 October 1998 a further 35 projects
across the country which had been awarded Lottery funds totalling £9,818,381
million. Amongst these was:
"Sheffield Town Trust:
Grant awarded: £365,000. - - - Total project cost: £490,000. This award
is towards a major sculpture for Town Hall Square, part of Sheffield's programme
of public art commissioning." [1]
In the past the site at the top of Fargate has been home to two other sculptures,
Queen Victoria and the Jubilee Memorial (both now moved to Endcliffe Park).
The project was organised to capture the imaginations of the people of Sheffield.
It would also create a focal point at the top of Fargate in Town Hall Square
which has been remodelled as part of the "Heart of the City" scheme.
In 1997 a national advertisement produced nearly 100 applications from artists
who wished to be considered for this project.
Three artists were selected to produce maquettes for public exhibition and
consultation before the final selection process. These artists were Shirazeh
Houshiary, Mike Lyons and Bill Woodrow. An exhibition of their "Sculpture
Proposals for Town Hall Square" was held at the Graves Art Gallery, Sheffield
from December 13th 1997 to January 24th 1998.
The exhibition at the Graves Art Gallery canvassed visitors' views on the
three proposals. From the outset local press opinion was solidly against
the piece. A lot of local sentiment was focussed on the Goodwin Fountain
which was to be removed and redesignated as the new fountain in the Peace
Gardens, and which subsequently happened anyway. These events took place
not long before local government elections and the majority party in the
Council, who subsequently lost heavily at the same elections, were understandably
unwilling to oppose what they perceived as popular opinion against the piece.
The suggestion was made that the piece be re-located, but the artist , who
conceived the work as site specific, and the Town Trust were unwilling to
do this.
Negotiations for a solution to this impasse were sought but eventually the
project was abandoned.
References.
Much of this information comes directly from a leaflet produced to publicise
the exhibition at the Graves Art Gallery.
This
page maintained by Dave
Ball
Slide Collection, Learning and IT Services
Last
updated
September 5, 2006